Lately, I have been reading several books trying to understand and better come to grips with the roots of antisemitism in Christendom. How did we ever strip the Jewishness of our Messiah and dress Him in Egyptian garb?
At some point I will review the books, but suffice it to say, the poison of antisemitism and the attack against the roots of the faith begin early and with very influential church ‘fathers.’ One such highly regarded ‘father’ is John Chrysostom. He may well be the vilest of the early offenders, but both the Eastern Orthodox and the Roman Catholic churches hold him in highest regard and thus embrace much of his teaching. That which they do not embrace openly is surely read and influential in many circles.
Chrysostom, nicknamed the Golden Mouth, wrote and delivered a particularly inflammatory series of homilies (sermons) titled Against the Jews that are available even today. He should have stuck to his series out of the Gospels or Epistles, as these eight antisemitic diatribes caused incalculable damage to relations between Christians and Jews and fueled innumerable pogroms against the Jews. He needed his vile mouth to be washed out with soap!
Allan Gould collected and edited quotes both positive and negative from famous and influential people from all walks of life and generations in a book now on my shelf, What Did They Think of the Jews? Gould quotes from Chrysostom’s homilies,
[How can Christians dare] have the slightest converse [with Jews], most miserable of all men [Homily 4:1]…[who are] lustful, rapacious, greedy, perfidious bandits….Inveterate murderers, destroyers, men possessed by the devil [whom] debauchery and drunkenness have given them the manners of the pig and the lusty goat. They know only one thing, to satisfy their gullets, get drunk, to kill and maim one another… They are impure and impious… (1:4). …they have surpassed the ferocity of wild beasts, for they murder their offspring and immolate them to the devil (1:6). …[The synagogue is a place of] shame and ridicule 91:3) …the domicile of the devil, as is also the soul of the Jews (1:4, 6); [their houses of worship] an assembly of criminals … a den of thieves … a cavern of devils, an abyss of perdition (1:2, 6:6) … [their rites are] criminal and impure; [their religion] a disease (3:1). [The Jews are corrupt because of their] odious assassination of Christ 96:4) … no expiation possible, no indulgence, no pardon (6:2). [Why Christians must hate Jews:] he who can never love Christ enough will never have done fighting against those [Jews] who hate Him (7:1). Flee, then, their assemblies, flee their houses, and far from venerating the synagogue because of the books it contains, hold it in hatred and aversion for the same reason (1:5). … I hate the synagogue precisely because it has the law and the prophets … I hate the Jews also because they outrage the law.
His quotes from Chrysostom were so choppy that I had to order the book and do more searching, only to find that the full quotes, pages and pages previously linked, are equally poisonous vitriol against the Jews.
Most of Christendom is oblivious to this hate coming from the church fathers, and when confronted with it the general response is one of excuse making and justifying on the one hand while assuming this has no measurable effect on us today. Frankly, both responses are horrifying and nothing could be further from the truth.
Even a pea-sized brain should recognize that hate to that degree for the Jews, particularly early in ministry, will affect every aspect of theology espoused by Chrysostom. With his Christian ‘love,’ is it any wonder Christendom has had <sarcasm> so much </sarcasm> success among the Jews?
Oh, yes. I forgot. We get to ignore the Scriptures that we don’t like. You know, verses such as ‘…to the Jew first…’ and …love your neighbor…’ and ‘…God has not rejected His people…’
Until there is open repentance, open grief, open shame and serious deep apologies to Judah, we will be a blot on the name of Messiah! Until we can humble ourselves and admit that God’s plan is much greater and more glorious than our selfish replacement theology, we will flounder in weakness and division.
Almost every aspect of Christian theology is in some way affected by antisemitism and John Chrysostom, Mr. ‘Golden Mouth’ himself, shoulders at least part of the blame.
We’ll look next at the putrid waste that came out of Martin Luther’s mouth that was used by Adolf Hitler to justify killing 6,000,000 innocents while the German church largely looked the other way.
Father, forgive me for any antisemitic thoughts or theologies I have knowingly or unknowingly espoused. I repent and ask that You continue to reveal Your great love and unchanging promises to Judah, and in your time reveal to them their Mashaich! Help me to see and enter into ways to show Judah Your love as You fulfill in them the everlasting covenant You made with Abraham and his descendants. Amein!
Very helpful post Pete! I look forward to the rest of them on this subject.
And the verse he who does not love His brother who he can see cannot love Yah whom he can’t see-1 John 4:20
Looking for this day for sure:
Isa 11:13 And the envy of Ephraim shall turn off; and Judah’s foes shall be cut off. Ephraim shall not envy Judah, and Judah shall not trouble Ephraim.
Interesting painting of this guy. So much symbolism.
Yeah. Searched his name for art and all of them were loaded with pagan occult signs. Crazy obvious! Granted, painted centuries later, but shows the heart of the RCC!
AMEIN!! I look to that day as well! Between now and then, we can do our part or expose the error and love our neighbor as ourselves!! Only through that, and the work of our Father in both our hearts, can we build the trust for that relationship to genuinely be revived!
I would not care, even if all the ridicules lies told about Jews were true.
I would just love them even more !
It is Yah’s doing !!!
We ARE ECHAD !!!
The more I read and hear about these things, I am dumbfounded as to how anyone could call themselves by their name. How did they ever get a following!! I hope Yuhudah can get past all that hatred and trust us.
Pingback: The (Not So) Quotable Church Fathers: Various Early ‘fathers’ | natsab
Thank you Pete, Saint John was a peach, wasn’t he! After reading about him a number of years ago I was aghast to hear him quoted (not his antiSemetic vitriol, of course) from a bible study leader and then later the Pastor. I felt sick. I wondered if they even knew, they were both seminary trained (Westminster?), or just didn’t care.
Thanks again Pete.
Honestly, I have a seminary degree and everyday I learn things that I think, ‘Surely, they told this to me and I just didn’t hear….’ But, the reality is, most pastors I talk to have no clue and then, when mentioned, discussed, the wall goes up and they prefer ignorance.
Many will justify with some poor excuses, or claim that somehow the person discussed, Chrysostom, Calvin, Luther, kept these views in a box and it really didn’t affect their theological positions, but you and I both know, nothing could be further from the truth. this poison, like a drop of arsenic in a punch bowl, affects every corner, every ounce, every drop. ALL of a person’s theology is tainted by a negative view of Jews resulting in a warped perspective of EVERYTHING!
Bottom-line, there are a huge number of commentaries and theologians I avoid unless forced to read and then exceedingly critically because I know the poison they contain!
Christendom has some HUGE work ahead of it if they are to have any relevance to the Jews. Frankly, I believe we are approaching the great divide wherein most will choose apostasy over repentance.
Pingback: The Lion of the Tribe of Jew.. D’uh!! | natsab
Pingback: Christendom and the Sin of Jeroboam | natsab